06-03-2008, 12:34 PM
Armando Ramos Wrote:Don Dresden Wrote:1. Was Harris's paper reviewed?
a) Yes
b) No
2. If the answer to the previous question is "Yes," identify the person or persons who reviewed it.
3. If the answer to question 1 is "Yes," were any errors found in the paper?
a) Yes
b) No
Can Canadians plead the Fifth?
Was it reviewed? The journal's editor claimed it wasn't -- that it somehow got in by mistake -- except that he earlier apparently sent an email accepting Harris' paper. I read both the acceptance and the retraction, since Harris forwarded both verbatim to the list -- and I just don't know what actually happened at the journal's end. Heck -- the editor of the journal didn't seem to know either.
Errors? The sci.math crowd says yes. I wouldn't personally know -- it's not my branch of mathematics and I didn't read the paper except in passing.
My involvement in the mess had to do with the journal's behavior, not with the content of the paper itself.
As for psychosis -- Neilist has loudly and publicly falsely accused me of being a pedophile -- just because he's pissed at me -- and you give him credit for being level headed -- which means-- as far as I am concerned -- you are insincere in your pursuit of any reasonable discourse. Those kinds of false accusations -- in response to what? He doesn't like that I didn't do what he asked me to do. That's no rational for what he's been up to. None whatsoever.
Anyway... I don't see the point in it. You're hitching your wagon to one mighty ornery horse, fellah. Good luck with that.

