05-12-2011, 01:48 PM
(05-12-2011, 11:20 AM)Ben Johnson Wrote: Kind of glad I'm not a lawyer but why do juries like to find otherwise innocent people guilty of obstruction? Makes no frigging sense.
Most juries have no clue what is going on. Not being criminals or lawyers, they don't understand the legal system, don't understand what is happening, and don't understand the instructions given to them by the judge.
The natural inclination of sociable people is to compromise in order to reach a consensus. The least onerous sounding charge becomes the halfway point at which the "guilty as sin" votes meet the "innocent" votes.
Prosecutors typically over-charge defendants, probably because they are well aware of the natural tendency of jurors to reach consensus at lower levels than the original charge. Jurors see 97 counts of bad actions and hear hours of testimony about what a prick the defendant is, and figure the guy must have done something, even if they can't get a handle on what it is exactly.
Likewise, this is why you get people copping to ridiculous things to avoid going to trial on more serious charges. If Martha Stewart can go to jail just for denying she did anything wrong, anyone can go to jail for anything, whether or not it actually was illegal. Ask Dixie.

