06-03-2008, 09:49 AM
OK -- I looked in my archival folders, and found the communications in question. The whole thing started at 5/4/2004, when James announced his paper was accepted by the journal. Then it turned sour on 5/7/2004 when the journal then claimed they had a clerical error. James sent to the list the acceptance email the journal had originally sent him -- and it appears it wasn't a clerical error, but a "back peddle" on the journal's part. The whole thread goes on for a few days after that, ending with James agreeing to revise his paper and move on.
There's no "misrememberance" here -- I tend to save my emails. Even the elist ones. This case was no exception.
There's no "misrememberance" here -- I tend to save my emails. Even the elist ones. This case was no exception.

